Sample · Marketa · Equip Your Sales Team

Battlecards

One card per opponent your team meets: the 30-second answer, why you win and lose, objections, questions and proof.

All samples · These samples were built for a real client, a billing company for behavioral health providers. Every company, person, story and number from that client is invented here. Public news, rulings and rules are real and link to their sources.

NorthsteadBattlecards · internal · refreshed monthly

Battlecards for the sales team

One card per opponent the team actually meets, saved to the shared sales folder

Keeping billing in-house

The biggest competitor is the prospect's own team
Share of losses

38 of 71 deals lost since January were marked "stayed in house" (54%). From your CRM

What they say

"In-house has to be cheaper." "I'd rather be frustrated with my own people than a vendor." From your playbook

The math they use

Salaries only. One outpatient network priced a six-person team at about $430K a year. From your playbook

What it leaves out

Benefits, turnover and backfill, software, supervision, and the revenue an understaffed team never chases.

When in-house fits

Your sales lead's rule of thumb: around $60M to $70M in annual billing. Not a published figure.

Watch the label

"Stayed in house" may also hold no-decision losses, so the real number could be lower.

The 30-second answer

Don't argue that in-house is wrong. Offer to pressure-test their model with a revenue cycle review, and say plainly that sometimes the answer is to stay in-house. Then rebuild the number with them, and put a middle path on the table: their billing lead, with Northstead's team and tools behind them.

Why we win
  • The real cost shows upFully loaded cost, backfill and unworked denials usually change the comparison.
  • Key-person riskIf their billing lead quits, claims stop. A Northstead team has built-in backup.
  • A middle pathCo-sourcing or project work keeps control in-house without carrying all the risk.
Why we lose confirm with win and loss notes
  • Control matters more than costSome owners would rather manage their own people, whatever the math says.
  • They are big enoughAbove roughly $60M to $70M in billing, in-house can make sense.
  • No urgencyNothing is broken this quarter, so nothing changes. This is where no-decision losses hide.

Head to head

NorthsteadIn-house team
When the billing lead quitsA team with built-in backupClaims slow or stop until a hire is trained
Denials under $200Worked as part of the jobOften left untouched
Payer ratesFree benchmark by billing code against peersRarely checked
ReportingClaim-level view across systems, exportableBuilt by hand in spreadsheets
CostA share of collected cash, so a denial costs us tooFixed salaries, whatever gets collected

Objections and answers

They say

"In-house has to be cheaper."

You say

Maybe. Let's check with your real numbers: fully loaded salaries, backfill when someone leaves, software, and the denials nobody gets to. If it still wins, we'll tell you.

They say

"I'd rather be frustrated with my own people."

You say

Then keep your billing lead and put our team behind them. Co-sourcing keeps control where it is and takes the key-person risk off the table.

They say

"We can hire one more biller."

You say

One more biller doesn't cover the next resignation. Ask what happened to cash the last time someone left.

Trap-setting questions
  1. If your billing lead resigned tomorrow, how long until claims went out on time again?
  2. Who is working the denials under $200 today?
  3. What did your team collect against expected payment last quarter, by payer?
Discovery questions to qualify
  1. What does your in-house cost include beyond salaries?
  2. How much of your A/R is older than 90 days, and who owns it?
  3. What reporting do you build by hand each month?
  4. Which work would you keep in-house if you could hand off the rest?

Proof to use

$312K nobody worked

A Carolina outpatient group's self-taught biller was leaving; a review of old claims found $312K in zero-pay claims no one had followed up.

Say aloud only
Weekend spreadsheets

"I spend every other weekend building spreadsheets just to see what each payer owes us." (practice director)

Say aloud only
Approved stats

96%+ collection rate, 99.2% clean claim rate, 41 days average to payment. Collection rate means insurance cash collected against expected payment, not counting patient balances.

OK in writing
What Elevate keeps fresh

An in-house cost check the rep fills in with the prospect (salaries, benefits, backfill, software, supervision, unworked denials), refreshed monthly with current loss reasons.

Kestrel Revenue Partners

The biggest name in behavioral health billing deals
Founded

2015, Brentwood, TN; founder-led

Size

Claims 350+ employees; one data provider counts about 160

Ownership

PE firm took a majority stake in 2021; current owner not public

Footprint

Claims 38 states and $1.1B+ collected a year (its own figures)

Sells

Outsourced billing from detox through outpatient and MAT, plus its own records and billing software

Pricing

Not public

The 30-second answer

Kestrel is the big name, and it sells size. Northstead's answer is fit and follow-through: billing in the prospect's own EHR, a named team on every account, and only approved, defined numbers. Ask what Kestrel looks like if the prospect keeps its own EHR.

Why we win
  • Works in the prospect's EHRNorthstead bills in any EHR. Kestrel publicly names only its own software.
  • A named teamA dedicated client manager, a billing team with backup, and in-house utilization review.
  • Defined numbersApproved stats with a stated definition, against large unaudited headline claims.
Why we lose confirm with win and loss notes
  • Size and brand"Largest" and $1.1B collected persuade owners who want the safe choice.
  • One vendor for software and billingA prospect replacing its EHR may like both from one company.
  • PresenceKestrel exhibits and sponsors across the event calendar.

Head to head

NorthsteadKestrel
EHRs named publiclyAny EHR; most experience on two leading platformsIts own software only
Who works the accountNamed client manager, billing team, in-house reviewNot stated publicly
Scale claimsApproved, defined stats350+ staff, 38 states, $1.1B+ (its own figures)
PricingA share of collected cashNot public

Objections and answers

They say

"Kestrel is the biggest billing company in behavioral health."

You say

Size isn't who works your claims. Ask who your named team is, where they sit, and how many accounts each one carries.

They say

"Kestrel collects $1.1B a year."

You say

That's their own figure, and an older page of theirs said 16 states where the new release says 38. Ask how they define collections, then compare to a defined number.

They say

"Kestrel gives us the EHR and billing together."

You say

If you want to keep your EHR, ask which named EHRs they bill in today.

Trap-setting questions
  1. If you keep your current EHR, which named EHRs does Kestrel bill in today, and can you talk to a client on yours?
  2. How many people will work your account, are they US-based, and can that go in the contract?
  3. Who owns Kestrel today, and what happens to your contract and data if it is sold during the term?
Discovery questions to qualify
  1. Are you keeping your current EHR, or replacing it in the next year?
  2. Who on your side will talk to the billing team every week?
  3. What would you need in the contract about staffing and data ownership?

Proof to use

Approved stats

96%+ collection rate, 99.2% clean claim rate, 41 days average to payment.

OK in writing
A public switch

A five-site program in Kestrel's home state moved to Northstead; live in May. Public press release.

OK in writing
Part of the operation

"It doesn't feel like an outside service. She knows our patients and our payers." (SUD program leader)

Say aloud only
What Elevate keeps fresh

Kestrel watched monthly: events, releases, hires and ownership news, so the rep knows what changed before the call.

Lines marked "from your playbook" come from the client's own objection playbook. Customer stories marked "say aloud only" stay out of anything written to prospects. A third card, on the low-price local biller, is in the real set.

How to hire your first teammate

Pick a teammate and start at Level 2, free for 30 days. No card needed to start. A short intake tells it about your business, and the first delivery arrives within 48 hours.

Not sure which teammate fits? Talk to a coach